In a way, it is much easier to learn from adverse, difficult, or unpleasant circumstances. This is because we are forced to pay attention to what is going on. The presence of what we hate or fear and the absence of what we accept as normal or cherish, also forces us to examine our beliefs. Loss of what we value or gaining what we loathe, makes it harder to take norms or benefits for granted.
This applies also to living under a President who has spent his political campaigns and years governing in tearing down norms and institutions that we have come to depend on will always be there for us. For so many of us, living under President Donald Trump has been highly eventful. We have had to pay attention to things we may not have before. We have had to re-evaluate our belief systems. We have been unable to take what we have come to depend on, for granted.
So what can we say that we should have learned from the Presidency of Donald Trump?
1). Some existing laws need to be changed. Those of us who have followed the many legal angles surrounding Donald Trump can claim that we have received an informal law school education! These past three plus years have brought many TV appearances by former prosecutors, current defense attorneys, and other legal scholars. We went through two years of a Russia investigation. Whatever you think of that investigation and its outcome, you may have educated yourself about the legal system if you have followed it.
We have observed Donald Trump do many things that cannot be prosecuted but proved extremely controversial. And many of us have observed the President and others, during his 2016 campaign and afterwards, do unsavory, selfish, immoral, and incredibly foolish things. Yet Robert S Mueller and his team were unable to establish evidence of a conspiracy with Russia to interfere with the 2016 campaign--despite many contacts with Russian officials.
Throughout his 2016 campaign and Presidency, Donald Trump has done many corrupt, selfish, stupid, even cruel things. He has invited Russia to hack Hillary Clinton's emails. A videotape captures him bragging about his prowess in sexually assaulting women. He has fired many officials without cause. He has demanded loyalty from those who work with and for him. He has lied countless times to the public. He has bullied those under him into doing things they found morally or ethically problematic. He has called for the prosecution of political opponents.
Donald Trump evidently is not stupid. Yes, it seems that he has had a "knack" for skirting the edge of the law without actually breaking it. It seems that he knows how the stretch the law without actually crossing the line and breaking it. He has enjoyed what is known as "Presidential immunity," protection against prosecution because of the office he hold. How many times have I exclaimed: "No President should have so much power!" or "I never heard of anyone with so many 'rights!' " Does this indicate that maybe existing laws need to be changed or created?
2). People don't always act as expected. Just observing the conduct and actions of many in the Trump Administration should tell us that. Many of these officials have spent their entire careers serving with character and honor. The same holds true for many elected officials, particularly those in the GOP. Generally, they also have served with honor and integrity.
Sadly, during these past few years of Trump, things changed. Many in Trump's staff and Cabinet, likely fearing their boss's wrath, remained silent even when he did things that many saw as abhorrent and even dangerous. Many elected officials, even most who ran strong primaries against Trump in 2016, unexpectedly became staunch allies of his during his Presidency.
Of course, it goes without saying that many of us have not expected the attitudes and actions of many Trump supporters. Donald Trump has done many controversial things, even before he ever became President. On videotape, he bragged about getting by with sexually assaulting women. He invited Russia to hack Hillary Clinton's emails. On videotape, he mocked a reporter with a disability. He called Mexicans criminals and rapists.
As President, Donald Trump imposed a travel ban on Muslim countries. He has appointed many people who have been both inexperienced and morally compromised. He has called for the prosecutions of political opponents. He has obstructed investigations into himself and others. He has called the media "fake news" and the "enemy of the people." He has separated many migrant children from their families, some seemingly forever. He has made it a point to bully, intimidate, and punish anyone who dares to "cross" him." And, yet, many women, poor people, and people of color have voted for this President in 2020.
3). Democracy must not be taken for granted. If you live in the United States, you live in a country where you can vote if you are a citizen. Multiple institutions exist for the purpose of keeping all of us safe and to hold wrongdoers accountable. We have typically trusted these institutions to be there for us. However, we got Donald Trump, a man fiercely determined to attack and batter these trusted institutions and resulting, established norms. To be fair, many have been mistrusting many of these before the rise of Donald Trump. It was for that very reason, among other things, that he was able to get into the White House.
Donald Trump has been both a symptom and a cause of so many of what ails us. No aspect of what came to be known as the "deep state" has escaped unscathed. Donald Trump has battered the CIA, the FBI, the CDC, and even the military. He has fired perfectly good officials from these institutions, in many cases replacing them with "loyalists" who have politicized these institutions. He has done the same with other institutions.
Donald Trump has battered and shattered so many norms. He has fired many officials, mostly because they have crossed him or criticized him in some way. Often, he has replaced them with "yes people" and "trump loyalists" Doing this has forced us to pay attention to many norms that we were able to take for granted before. Over and over, he has called media "fake news" and the "enemy of the people." Many officials have resigned in protest. They could not in clear conscience work under circumstances where they would face pressures to do things deemed to be unethical, immoral, even criminal.
To be fair, some who resigned from the CDC in protest, did state that the CDC had faced barriers during the AIDS epidemic. "We could have saved more lives" and "More infections could have been avoided." But politicization, even then, was not as severe as has become under the Donald Trump Presidency. In fact, the situation became so bad that Joe Biden has benefited from many voters who based their vote on the need to "save our democracy." How can we take democracy be taken for granted again?
4). Neither major party holds all human life as valuable. Actually, I was always somewhat aware of this. Yet this was powerfully reinforced during the Presidency of Donald Trump. Throughout his whole term, Trump has shown disdain for the lives of immigrants, people of color, women, and anyone who had the courage to stand up to him or hold him accountable. He has even shown contempt for members of the military. Of course, he has shown utter contempt for virtually all his political opponents. And yet, his policies and communication with white right Evangelical Christians and the pro-life movement has evinced regard and respect for the lives of the unborn and their right to live.
Donald Trump has made the sanctity of unborn lives a priority throughout his Presidency. The pro-life movement have anointed him as "the most pro-life President in United States history." But Donald Trump has never shown a consistent life ethic. Far from it! His Vice-President, Mike Pence, also is strongly pro-life about abortion. His loyalty to Trump has called his consistent life ethic into question, however. Trump's and Pence's ethics line up with their party.
In President-Elect, Joe Biden and Vice-President-Elect, Kamala Harris, this principle works in reverse. According to to his past record and statements, Biden has demonstrated regard and respect for the lives of those Trump shows disdain for. Biden consistently shows empathy for immigrants, people of color, women, and anyone deemed vulnerable. So has Harris. Even the past controversial "Crime" bill, which Biden authored, was set up to fight crime out of empathy for crime victims. It contains elements like the Violence against Women's Act. Yet the pro-life movement and religious right Evangelicals have a major beef with Joe Biden.
There is one people group which Biden now shows complete disregard for--the unborn. He has promised to "uphold Roe" via law and repeal the Hyde Amendment. Harris isn't only pro-choice but proudly pro-abortion. As California Attorney General, she has gone after pro-life pregnancy resource centers as well as a pro-life whistleblower against Planned Parenthood. Despite their character, competence and empathy, neither Biden nor Harris show a consistent life ethic. Biden's and Harris's ethics line up with their party.
5). Both character and ideology matter in a leader. Throughout his Presidency, Donald Trump has not demonstrated much character. He has shown consistent dishonesty through his lies to the public. He has shown greed through severely unethical business practices. He has evinced poor impulse control though numerous public outbursts caught on tape. Trump has demonstrated selfishness by making it a point to make things about himself, no matter what goes on with his country. He has shown cruelty and lack of empathy through separating migrant children from his families; frequently, he has failed to show empathy in response to national crises. He has evinced racism in calling certain groups criminals, spreading false information about "caravans" in 2018, and failing to clearly condemn white supremacist groups.
Yet Donald Trump has shown an ideology that has been so morally acceptable that the religious Right have strongly supported him. He has garnered much praise and support from them due to his anti-abortion stance and solid support for religious liberty. In exchange, pro-life voters and religious Right voters have overwhelmingly voted for Trump both in 2016 and 2020.
The principle of character and policy work in reverse for Joe Biden. Throughout much of his life, including in public service, he has displayed many virtues. He has shown empathy, over and over, in his conduct, attitude, and policies. Throughout the general election and transition, he has demonstrated restraint and discipline in the face of Trump's attacks on him. Despite his rather problematic civil rights record, Biden has evinced respect for the lives, histories, and needs of anyone with difference of race, ethnicity, disability, and more. He has shown depth and vulnerability, particularly when he addresses the multiple past tragedies in his past. Biden has demonstrated consistency in messaging throughout his primary, the general election, and now. His VP, Kamala Harris, has also shown these qualities. In addition, arguably even more than Biden, she has shown strength, toughness of personality, and the knack of saying the right thing at the right time.
On the other hand, the Biden/Marris stance on abortion and weakness on religious liberty turn off religious Right Christians and the pro-life movement. For all his virtues, Joe Biden hasn't earned the support or trust of those who typically vote based on the sanctity of life or religious liberty values. In the eyes of Trump supporters, character did not make up for what they view as a fundamentally morally lax platform.
These past almost four years may have been a rough ride. They may have forced us to ask questions we may never have had to ask before. But what a learning experience this has been--informal lessons in civics, law, and even psychology!